Sistema de Pontuação USSP (Score)

Brainstorm sobre sistema de score inicial para provedores:

Para a fase 1, o sistema de score deve ser simples, técnico e pouco punitivo. Nas fases posteriores serão adicionadas mais camadas.

 

 

Alternativa 1: Os provedores que forem certificados pelo onboarding começam com 100 pontos, e a reputação é reduzida baseada em incidentes.

Onboarding & Initial Score

• Providers must pass the Onboarding Test Suite to be certified.
• Once approved, they start with a score of 100 and can operate normally.

👉 Onboarding only determines whether they enter the system (pass/fail), but all approved providers begin at the same reputation level (100).

---

Reputation Deductions: How Providers Lose Points

• Reputation is dynamically reduced based on system failures, rule violations, or poor service quality.
• The severity of the issue determines the penalty (light, moderate, or severe).

Issue Type	Description	Points Deducted
Minor Violation ⚠️	Slight delay in reporting logs, temporary downtime (under 1 hour), minor compliance issue	-2 to -5 points
Moderate Violation 🛑	Repeated reporting delays, 1-5 hours of downtime, incorrect flight data, failure in an audit	-10 to -20 points
Severe Violation ❌	Regulatory non-compliance, system crash >5 hours, security breach, airspace safety risk	-30 to -50 points
Critical Violation 🚨	Major security failure, fraudulent activity, repeated severe violations	-50 to -100 points (license revoked)

 

 

Alternativa 2: O processo de onboarding resulta em um score inicial de acordo com os testes

How a New Provider Acquires Score in the Reputation System

A new USSP (UAS Service Supplier) must earn an initial score through an Onboarding Test Suite before operating within the BR-UTM ecosystem. The certification process will determine their starting reputation and ensure only compliant providers enter the system.

---

Onboarding Test Suite & Initial Score Allocation

A new provider must pass a series of tests that assess compliance, integration, and operational capability. Their initial score will be based on performance in these tests, setting their starting reputation.

Test Suite Evaluation (Maximum Score: 80 - 100 Points)

Test Category	Description	Score Range
System Compliance Test	Verifies adherence to BR-UTM and INTER-USS standards.	✅ +20 points if passed
Security & Data Protection Test	Ensures proper encryption, authentication, and secure API handling.	✅ +15 points if passed
Log Quality & Reporting Test	Tests accuracy, completeness, and timeliness of logs.	✅ +15 points if passed
Interoperability Test	Confirms successful integration with other USSPs in the network.	✅ +20 points if passed
Operational Stability Test	Evaluates system uptime, response time, and performance under stress.	✅ +20 points if passed
Safety Compliance & Incident Response Test	Assesses ability to handle incidents and enforce flight restrictions.	✅ +10 points if passed

Pass/Fail Criteria

• Minimum Passing Score: 75 points (Provider is certified and allowed to operate).
• High-Performance Providers: 90+ points get a trusted status with full operational capabilities.
• Failed Test (<75 points): The provider must reapply after fixing the identified issues.

👉 Initial score becomes the provider’s starting reputation, which will be dynamically adjusted based on performance.

---

How the Onboarding Score Relates to Reputation

After passing onboarding, providers will be placed into one of three tiers based on their score:

Initial Score	Tier	Operational Status	Reputation Status
90 - 100	Trusted Provider ✅	Full operational capability	High Reputation (Preferred Provider)
75 - 89	Certified Provider ⚠️	Allowed to operate normally	Standard Reputation
Below 75	Not Certified ❌	Cannot operate	Rejected - Must retake tests

• Trusted Providers gain faster approvals and access to premium services.
• Certified Providers operate normally but need to improve their reputation over time.
• Rejected Providers must fix their issues and reapply.

---

Maintaining & Improving Reputation Post-Certification

Once operational, a USSP’s reputation is continuously updated based on:

✅ Positive Actions (e.g., successful flights, compliance, high uptime) increase reputation.
❌ Negative Actions (e.g., violations, downtime, failed audits) decrease reputation.

A new provider can improve from a “Certified” to a “Trusted” status by maintaining:

• 90%+ uptime over 6 months
• Zero regulatory violations in the first 3 months
• High-quality log submissions