Sistema de Pontuação USSP (Score)
Brainstorm sobre sistema de score inicial para provedores:
Para a fase 1, o sistema de score deve ser simples, técnico e pouco punitivo. Nas fases posteriores serão adicionadas mais camadas.
Alternativa 1: Os provedores que forem certificados pelo onboarding começam com 100 pontos, e a reputação é reduzida baseada em incidentes.
Onboarding & Initial Score
- Providers must pass the Onboarding Test Suite to be certified.
- Once approved, they start with a score of 100 and can operate normally.
👉 Onboarding only determines whether they enter the system (pass/fail), but all approved providers begin at the same reputation level (100).
Reputation Deductions: How Providers Lose Points
- Reputation is dynamically reduced based on system failures, rule violations, or poor service quality.
- The severity of the issue determines the penalty (light, moderate, or severe).
| Issue Type | Description | Points Deducted |
|---|---|---|
| Minor Violation ⚠️ | Slight delay in reporting logs, temporary downtime (under 1 hour), minor compliance issue | -2 to -5 points |
| Moderate Violation 🛑 | Repeated reporting delays, 1-5 hours of downtime, incorrect flight data, failure in an audit | -10 to -20 points |
| Severe Violation ❌ | Regulatory non-compliance, system crash >5 hours, security breach, airspace safety risk | -30 to -50 points |
| Critical Violation 🚨 | Major security failure, fraudulent activity, repeated severe violations | -50 to -100 points (license revoked) |
Alternativa 2: O processo de onboarding resulta em um score inicial de acordo com os testes
How a New Provider Acquires Score in the Reputation System
A new USSP (UAS Service Supplier) must earn an initial score through an Onboarding Test Suite before operating within the BR-UTM ecosystem. The certification process will determine their starting reputation and ensure only compliant providers enter the system.
Onboarding Test Suite & Initial Score Allocation
A new provider must pass a series of tests that assess compliance, integration, and operational capability. Their initial score will be based on performance in these tests, setting their starting reputation.
Test Suite Evaluation (Maximum Score: 80 - 100 Points)
| Test Category | Description | Score Range |
|---|---|---|
| System Compliance Test | Verifies adherence to BR-UTM and INTER-USS standards. | ✅ +20 points if passed |
| Security & Data Protection Test | Ensures proper encryption, authentication, and secure API handling. | ✅ +15 points if passed |
| Log Quality & Reporting Test | Tests accuracy, completeness, and timeliness of logs. | ✅ +15 points if passed |
| Interoperability Test | Confirms successful integration with other USSPs in the network. | ✅ +20 points if passed |
| Operational Stability Test | Evaluates system uptime, response time, and performance under stress. | ✅ +20 points if passed |
| Safety Compliance & Incident Response Test | Assesses ability to handle incidents and enforce flight restrictions. | ✅ +10 points if passed |
Pass/Fail Criteria
- Minimum Passing Score: 75 points (Provider is certified and allowed to operate).
- High-Performance Providers: 90+ points get a trusted status with full operational capabilities.
- Failed Test (<75 points): The provider must reapply after fixing the identified issues.
👉 Initial score becomes the provider’s starting reputation, which will be dynamically adjusted based on performance.
How the Onboarding Score Relates to Reputation
After passing onboarding, providers will be placed into one of three tiers based on their score:
| Initial Score | Tier | Operational Status | Reputation Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 90 - 100 | Trusted Provider ✅ | Full operational capability | High Reputation (Preferred Provider) |
| 75 - 89 | Certified Provider ⚠️ | Allowed to operate normally | Standard Reputation |
| Below 75 | Not Certified ❌ | Cannot operate | Rejected - Must retake tests |
- Trusted Providers gain faster approvals and access to premium services.
- Certified Providers operate normally but need to improve their reputation over time.
- Rejected Providers must fix their issues and reapply.
Maintaining & Improving Reputation Post-Certification
Once operational, a USSP’s reputation is continuously updated based on:
✅ Positive Actions (e.g., successful flights, compliance, high uptime) increase reputation.
❌ Negative Actions (e.g., violations, downtime, failed audits) decrease reputation.
A new provider can improve from a “Certified” to a “Trusted” status by maintaining:
- 90%+ uptime over 6 months
- Zero regulatory violations in the first 3 months
- High-quality log submissions